Tag Archives: dep

Pennsylvania DEP Secretary Krancer exits through revolving door

Pennsylvania Secretary of Environmental Protection Michael Krancer announced last week that he was leaving the agency to lead the energy, petrochemical, and natural resources practice at Philadelphia-based law firm Blank Rome LLP, where he was a partner from 1992 to 1999.

Krancer’s administration of the Department of Environmental Protection during the fracking boom was mired with controversy, characterized as overly friendly to the natural gas industry and hostile to regulation and enforcement. His return to Blank Rome, which lobbies for natural gas clients and was a member of the Marcellus Shale Coalition until 2013, makes him the fifth DEP secretary since the agency was created to take a job connected to the oil and gas industry.

Continue reading Pennsylvania DEP Secretary Krancer exits through revolving door

The Pennsylvania “Environmental” Council

The Pennsylvania Environmental Council is an organization that the Public Accountability Initiative first touched upon in our recent report on the revolving door between Pennsylvania’s environmental regulators and the natural gas industry. The group is perhaps the most prominent voice on environmental issues in the state of Pennsylvania and often provides representatives to Commonwealth boards, commissions, and panels. Its mission statement reads:

The Pennsylvania Environmental Council (PEC) protects and restores the natural and built environments through innovation, collaboration, education and advocacy. PEC believes in the value of partnerships with the private sector, government, communities and individuals to improve the quality of life for all Pennsylvanians.

On the fracking issue, PEC has positioned itself as a moderate, calling itself “the voice of reason.” It has called for a severance tax in Pennsylvania, but supports drilling in the Marcellus asserting “[i]t is widely considered that the Marculle [sic] Shale play offers an abundant fuel to help bridge the gap between today’s energy portfolio and a future supply that reflects both a reduced carbon footprint and reduce dependence on foregin [sic] sources of energy.”

Continue reading The Pennsylvania “Environmental” Council

New DEP water contamination policies (again) raise the specter of political interference

This past March, the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection faced controversy when an e-mail leaked to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette revealed a new agency policy requiring any Marcellus Shale permitting or enforcement action to be approved by DEP executives and cleared by Secretary of Environmental Protection Michael Krancer. Under the new policy even notices of violation, previously issued by field inspectors or regional DEP offices, were required to be cleared by agency brass in Harrisburg. The policy, decried by environmental groups statewide, raised the specter of political interference in Pennsylvania’s regulation of fracking. Former DEP Secretary John Hanger called the new policy “exceptionally unwise” and said that it could “do nothing but crater public confidence in inspections and oversight of the industry.”

For Krancer, an appointee of Governor Tom Corbett, a decrease in the number of violations found by his department would help vindicate his vigorous stance against the federal government regulating fracking, which he feels should be left to state agencies. Indeed, in a Congressional hearing Krancer quoted a report from the University at Buffalo’s Shale Resources and Society Institute that (incorrectly) concluded that the incidence of major environmental incidents was decreasing based on the number of notices of violation issued by the DEP.

After a spate of bad press and at the insistence of 42 environmental and conservation, faith-based organizations, and businesses, the DEP rescinded the pre-approval policy a little more than a month after the directive issued.

Last month, another e-mail obtained by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette exposed another new DEP policy requiring reviews of notifications by top agency officials, this time for determinations that water has been contaminated by fracking in the Marcellus Shale. Previously, based on the results of laboratory testing of samples collected by water specialists, DEP district offices would send determination letters to residents and property owners whose water was affected. Under the new policy, contamination determinations must first be sent to the DEP headquarters in Harrisburg for review by Deputy Secretary for Oil and Gas Management Scott Perry and Michael Krancer.

Much like the rescinded policy from this spring, this directive requiring the approval of DEP Secretary Krancer over notifications of water contamination introduces the possibility of administrative interference in what should be a matter of test results and the plain language of the law. An e-mail from Deputy Secretary for Oil and Gas Management Perry indicates that only positive determinations of contamination from drilling operations are to be reviewed at the top level, though he asks to be apprised of negative determinations that “may generate media interest.”

The new notification policy came on the heels of meetings between DEP officials and Range Resources to contest water contamination letters sent to property owners whose supplies were contaminated by methane, likely due to gas drilling. According to Marcellus Money, a project of Common Cause PA and Conservation Voters of Pennsylvania, Range Resources executives and its political action committee have contributed $46,754.77 to Gov. Tom Corbett, who appointed Krancer, since 2009.

On top of the policy requiring top-level approval of contamination notifications, the DEP is facing scrutiny over the content of notification letters. Pennsylvania State Representative Jesse White has called for state and federal agencies to investigate the DEP for “alleged fraud and misconduct” after a DEP employee revealed in a deposition that the Office of Oil and Gas Management directed the Bureau of Laboratories to omit a number of heavy metals, some known carcinogens, and volatile organic compounds associated with fracking from water test reports. At the direction of the Office of Oil and Gas Management, the results of DEP’s laboratory tests for lithium, cobalt, chromium, boron and titanium as well as volatile organic compounds are witheld from reports to the oil and gas division and property owners.

These policies cast a shadow on the Department of Environmental Protection’s mission to “protect Pennsylvania’s air, land and water from pollution and to provide for the health and safety of its citizens through a cleaner environment.” They seem to show a calculated manipulation of information, at the risk of Pennsylvania residents, in order to make fracking in the Marcellus Shale seem safer and its regulation by the DEP more effective. The Office of Oil and Gas Management can reduce the apparent number of contamination instances by limiting the number of hazardous chemicals reported on water tests by the Bureau of Laboratories and by requiring all letters confirming water contamination to be approved by Secretary of Oil and Gas Management Scott Perry and Secretary of Environmental Protection Michael Krancer.

Neither Perry nor Krancer are chemists with the scientific experience one would expect necessary to determine whether fracking has contaminated a water supply. Rather, both are attorneys. Prior to heading the DEP, Krancer was general counsel for the energy company Exelon and previous to that he was a litigator for Blank Rome LLP, a law firm and lobbying group that represents a number of natural gas clients. Perry was the attorney for the DEP’s oil and gas division before being selected to head it.

Considering the serious health consequences possible from exposure to contaminated water, the apparent interference of top DEP administrators in public notifications about water contamination is cause for alarm. Michael Krancer is a staunch defender of his agency’s ability to effectively regulate the gas industry and Scott Perry has gone on record saying: “There has never been any evidence of fracking ever causing direct contamination of fresh groundwater in Pennsylvania or anywhere else.” But as long as Perry and Krancer are playing politics with water contamination notifications, the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection has effectively ceded its authority to make such determinations.